Showing posts with label red rock. Show all posts
Showing posts with label red rock. Show all posts

Saturday, 16 May 2020

Considering Beauty’s “Objective” Nature [Sociology w/photographic evidence]


We’ve always been told, “Beauty is in the Eye of the Beholder”; i.e. a subjective, personal, internal state. While that’s “true” there is more to it — maybe the most important part, beauty’s objective nature. 


Sociology

This blog offering is plagiarizing the scientific principles of Sociology to support the concept that beauty is also objective; i.e. create a hypothesis, predict behavior, observe repeated behavior patterns as objective evidence, and the evidence either supports or refutes the hypothesis.

Hypothesis

Beauty is a common, near universal, repeatable cognitive experience that people, in significant numbers, find esthetically pleasing and will seek being exposed to — will seek experiencing. 

The hypothesis can be objectively tested by measuring human behavior, without reliance on having to measure anyone’s internal subjective state. We can see and measure the behavior of people seeking beauty. 

Test Sample

Our test sample of beauty is randomly eroded rock [see previous blog post for evidence].  A benefit of this test sample is that it is not beautiful as the result of a deliberate human act. We can assume the randomly eroded rock did not consciously create itself for the pleasure of humans; i.e. there’s no bias in the test sample. 

[BTW in the case of human observed randomly eroded rock beauty, synonyms for beauty include awe, wonder, splendor, etc.]

Sociology: observed behavior as objective evidence

Humans stumble on beautiful randomly eroded rock, recognize it as a kind of beauty that will be widely appreciated, and create national parks such as Zion, Arches, Bryce Canyon, etc.  The confirmation of their hypothesis is the measurable behavior of millions of people showing up to experience the beauty. 

And the visitors are so confident in their good taste and the surrounding beauty, that they take selfies to send back home to family and friends.

Selfies with Randomly Eroded Rock Beauty

When I Google “the most beautiful national parks” I get answers such as…. https://travel.usnews.com/rankings/best-national-parks-in-the-usa/
“Today, 61 national parks in the United States draw more than 300 million visitors a year to unique natural wonders and unforgettable terrains.”

The objective nature of beauty is also important to artistic effort. Because of beauty’s objectivity, artists are able to [at least partially] predict and take advantage of a viewer’s reaction.  This is true even when the artist innovates beyond current “critical standards” of beauty; e.g. Vincent Van Gogh. 

And so on. Point made. 

Ooops, there’s more….

Sunsets

One of my fav sociology examples is people who go to the coast to watch the sunset.   



Sunsets include more than mere beauty.  They include a sense of ending/beginning, cosmic connection, transition, transcendence. 

Maybe it can be asserted that all natural beauty has a touch of the transcendent to it.  Yet sunsets seem more insistent about it.  But we’re here for beauty.  [Thoughts on transcendence may be another blog.  Maybe not.] 

People are drawn to sunsets regardless of their complexity.  They’ll show up for ho-hum sunsets.  So it seems like just the idea of a sunset is enough. They’ll walk to the water’s edge or out to the end of the pier to get “closer” to the sunset.   

Sunset viewers at the end of a tall pier


Actually, how close you are to the sunset is controlled by geometry: the curvature of the earth and the altitude of your eyeballs.

BTW when standing at water’s edge the horizon and therefore the sunset is about 3 miles away.  For some reason I was hoping it was farther away, as if farther away added to the grandeur.   

Hopefully that factoid doesn’t dull your response to your next sunset. ;--)

Cheers, Kurt







Monday, 4 May 2020

Let’s consider the beauty of randomly eroded rocks. [Photographic evidence provided.]

We’ve discussed why flowers are so excessively beautiful.  The answer seems to be intuitively obvious  --- “There they are,  you just have to look at them” --- and yet not fully rational, objectively understood. But Darwinianism is involved because it’s biology; e.g. eyeballs. Got it? ;--)

But the mystery of beauty deepens significantly when we try to critically understand the incredible beauty of many square miles of randomly eroded rock.  Rock! Randomly eroded!

[Actually, I don't know for sure why the Whole Thing is so beautiful. But let’s just take one step at a time. This time we’re doing randomly eroded rock beauty.]

Colorado Plateau in Utah

A few years ago we were driving from point-A to point-B through the Colorado Plateau in Utah. We came up over a rise and were suddenly exposed to so much beauty it literally took our breath away [proving that that's not just a saying, but can really happen]. What was there?... just an enormous landscape of randomly eroded rock, a lot of it sort of a burnt orange. [They like to call it “red rock”.  For a good time Google “Utah Red Rock”]

Random Erosion vs Darwinianism

By motivated extrapolation we can argue that Flowers are so excessively beautiful based on Darwinianism, and leave it at that.  But how’s that explain why randomly eroded rock is so grandly, expansively, excessively beautiful? Using the example above, we had never seen that Utah Red Rock scene before, yet we immediately perceived and were awed by its incredible beauty.

Sorry, I don’t have any photos from that specific example.  So I’ll borrow from lesser snapshots of the Grand Canyon and hope you can extrapolate from them.

   
 


Stumbled upon while Flying

A similar experience with randomly eroded rock beauty happened to me while solo flying in a single engine plane from Cody, Wyoming to Las Vegas, Nevada. My flight planning had been dominated by weather concerns, so I hadn’t paid much attention to the possibly interesting underlying terrain as I thought more about dodging weather threats and finding alternative airports, etc.; i.e. I was more concerned about an ugly emergency than a pretty sight.

Rain, low ceilings, high terrain

Low ceilings, high terrain

Towards the end of that flight, as the weather opened up, on a direct path to Las Vegas, I “stumbled” on the most beautiful sight I’ve ever experienced while flying a plane. 

I’d “stumbled” upon Zion National Park. 

The only camera I had with me was a video camera with a 1.1 megapixel still image capability, so please forgive the image quality not matching the scene below my plane.

 

 

 

The English Countryside

And for another example, just look at the inland countryside of England.  It’s exquisite.  And yet it’s almost all re-shaped by the hands of the natives scratching away at it for millennia, pushing all the stones from where they had rested naturally into miles of stone walls tracing beautiful forms and patterns, and erecting picture-perfect little home site vignettes and castle ruins in just right picture-perfect compositions. And all this beauty by a people whose world conquests are unrivaled by the Huns and Vikings. Give me a break! [Sorry, no snapshots.]

And then there’s cosmic beauty. Where does beauty end? [For a good time Google “eye of god nebula”.]

Beauty requires 3 things existing together as a system of irreducible complexity:
  • The thing itself creates, fulfills, and presents beauty
  • Individuals endowed with the private, personal capacity to recognize and appreciate beauty
  • And we have to agree between ourselves that beautiful is real and not insanity

Beauty seems to have something foundational to say about the Meaning of it All, and flowers and randomly eroded rocks are communicating that in poetry if not prose.

The mystery of beauty continues, and I’ll leave it at that.  And anyway it’s not my #1 focus photographically.  I’m more curious about exposing and developing transcendence.  Hmmm, “transcendence”…..

Onward, Kurt